I was popping about the 'net the other day and came to James Berardinelli's Top 100 Films list. I really like Mr. Berardinelli, and, like Yahoo, is one of the internet's original success stories. Beyond that, he's a fair and reasonable film reviewer, one that isn't bogged down with either an over-bloated sense of self-importance or delusions of intellectual superiority. So, while I don't always agree with him, I can walk away from one of his reviews still respecting both his opinion and my opinion of him as a person. This is most decidedly not something that I can say for most film critics.
One last thing before I get to the list. This is a list of my Favorite Films, not my list of the Best Films I've seen. My film knowledge is neither comprehensive nor without some very distinct biases and feel it would be arrogant and presumptuous to label any list I compile with adjectives purporting a sense of objective goodness.
The List:
1) Star Wars.
No surprise here, for anyone who knows me at all. Had George Lucas not just released the trilogy on DVD 2 months ago, Empire might top this list. But, frankly, the original is unsurpassed in its ability to captivate me and dominate my attention. I know all the dialogue and most of the editing cues (I've seen this film 160+ times) and while Empire might be a better film technically, Star Wars is still a revelation.
2) Patton
Like Mr. Berardinelli, I just love this film. Every time I find it while 'doing a lap' around the cable dial, I lose the rest of my day. 30+ times I've seen this movie and 30+ times I choke up during that lonely walk with Willy towards the windmill in the distance. Greatest Anti-War film every made.
3) The Maltese Falcon
A great story that is perfectly executed. This is a film that has risen in my estimation in the past few years. I watched this a few weeks ago and was just floored by the pace. For a talker, this film is amazingly snappy, just like the dialogue. Huston made all the right choices in terms of story, pacing and acting.
4) The Empire Strikes Back
Best single reversal in movie history.... "No. I am your father." It doesn't get any better than that, and I don't think it ever will. Vader bacame the greatest villain in film history with that one line of dialogue. A set up that took two movies to pay off. That revelation caused three years of anxiety in my youth that I've never been quite able to shake.
5) Fellowship of the Ring.
I make the distinction between the three LotR films simply because they are of varying quality. Fellowship blind-sided me as an adult the same way that Star Wars did as a child. It may have been timing, certainly, but there's no denying that this is a singularly powerful film experience that after 35+ viewings (including 9 times in the theatre) that has not diminshed. Just thinking about some of the images in this film makes me swallow hard. If Peter Jackson never makes another film it wouldn't matter. This is the best of the 3 films because it has the best screenplay. The others feel like drafts.
6) Blade Runner
The announcement of this film, and Harrision Ford's attachment to it, changed the direction of my intellectual life. Because of Blade Runner I discovered Philip K. Dick, and I have not been the same since, for which I am forever grateful. For those who want to translate a difficult book to film, this is your template. The Maltese Falcon had a source that was inherently filmable, all John Huston had to do was get out of Dashiell Hammitt's way. Hampton Fancher and David Peoples had a much harder task, and they succeeded brilliantly.
7) Dr. Strangelove
Let me state that I don't think this film is funny. It makes me laugh, but that doesn't matter. Dr. Strangelove is the single best description of the madness of power ever put on celluloid. The laughter this film generates is a defense mechanism against the unmitigated horror of centralized government: ours, theirs, yours, mine.
8) Full Metal Jacket
Again Mr. Kubrick makes us laugh simply because to not do so is to become like Pvt. Pyle. This film is so unbearably sad, and another indictment of centralized power's ability and naked desire to crush the individual. Ayn Rand doesn't hold a candle to Stanley Kubrick in celebrating the individual, simply because he truly understands how evil people work. The cartoon of Gunney Hartmann is just the logical conclusion of 'the ends justifying the means.' The saddest line of dialogue ever, "I am in a world of sh%t, but I am alive, and I am not afraid."
9) Miller's Crossing
This is the film that the Coen Brothers will never exceed (and if they do I'll be a very happy person). This is their greatest invention, not Fargo (which is also on the list). They've made a living making great films about stupid people, but Miller's Crossing is what happens when they make a film about smart people. The dialogue, editing, pace, performances, reversals are all first rate. Gabrial Byrne has never been better.
10) South Park: Bigger,Longer and Uncut
Okay, a comedy must make the top 10, because comedy is the hardest thing to do. Parker and Stone are unbelievably funny guys and South Park had me laughing harder, longer than any other film I've ever seen. Your mileage may vary, but for my tastes (which are admittedly a bit tweaked) it doesn't get any better than this. Couple that with some very astute social commentary and some drop-dead outstanding musical numbers and it's hard to think of a more successful blending of elements that should not mesh.
I'll be back later with 11-20.
Hope you've enjoyed it so far.
Ta,
Recent Comments